Okay, enough ranting from me. I thought I'd offer you a competition instead, with a MILLION POUND PRIZE !!!! I often hear the defenders of bankster capitalism claim that banks 'create wealth' or that private banks are vital to our economy. We can't tax or regulate them too much, for example, or we'll scare them away to Switzerland and Hong Kong, which would apparently be a disaster for us, because .. err .. well because banks 'create wealth' don't they?
I'd like to know more about this magical wealth creation process that occurs in banks, because I'm a bit hazy on the details at the moment and I'm sure some genius neo-liberal economist (perhaps one who works for a bank?) will be able to answer my question, given that I'm offering a good old capitalist incentive: what an economist might call a 'price signal'. That's right folks, I'm prepared to pay a MILLION BRITISH POUNDS to the first person to offer a satisfactory answer to the following simple question:
How do private banks create wealth?
That's it. Just post your answer in the comments, leaving a contact number or email and the first good answer will get £1,000,000. That's a MILLION POUNDS.
Small print: Of course, you will not object if I pay this in the form of a credit card specially issued by the newly created Bank of Insane Gibberish, with £1,000,000 credit on it (based on the £10 note I hold in my piggy bank as cash reserves).
Dispatches from the libertarian left, punctuated with science, culture ... and poetry.
Showing posts with label banking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label banking. Show all posts
Wednesday, 26 October 2011
Saturday, 8 October 2011
Anarchy in the USA
Even the mainstream media is now aware that there is something approaching an uprising going on in New York and other US cities right now. At least, if it were happening in an Arab country, our media would certainly be calling it an uprising, albeit a fairly peaceful one, if we overlook the copious violence coming from the police, as is usually the case, regardless of where in the world you are. I'm not going to offer any detailed analysis of this phenomenon. Instead, I leave you with a poem, the first version of which was written on the inauguration of President Obama in 2008. The basic message is in tune with those protesters occupying Wall Street today; that power must belong again to the people and that no leader can ever be trusted to deliver the people's will:
Anarchy in the USA
I woke up to a dream of hope:
the silent hordes who’d been asleep,
possessed for one ecstatic moment
of love before that love is spent.
For now, instead of begging bowls,
they raise their cups and think of schools,
clean water, liberty and rice,
in place of war and pestilence.
Who is the man who’d be a god,
and slake our thirst for more than blood?
But we have gorged ourselves on gods
and soaked our claws in sunny words,
and now we’re sick, too sick to swallow
the honeycomb promises of kings who borrow
magic from the myriad-headed hydra
(serpent slayer of the ancient Maya).
While Fear and Faith stand by the throne,
the world still wears a golden chain –
now will some god-king give the command
to throw all idols to the ground?
No. Hail the one, who would be chief –
he is you, and me, and a turning leaf.
![]() |
| Occupy Wall Street |
I woke up to a dream of hope:
the silent hordes who’d been asleep,
possessed for one ecstatic moment
of love before that love is spent.
For now, instead of begging bowls,
they raise their cups and think of schools,
clean water, liberty and rice,
in place of war and pestilence.
Who is the man who’d be a god,
and slake our thirst for more than blood?
But we have gorged ourselves on gods
and soaked our claws in sunny words,
and now we’re sick, too sick to swallow
the honeycomb promises of kings who borrow
magic from the myriad-headed hydra
(serpent slayer of the ancient Maya).
While Fear and Faith stand by the throne,
the world still wears a golden chain –
now will some god-king give the command
to throw all idols to the ground?
No. Hail the one, who would be chief –
he is you, and me, and a turning leaf.
Thursday, 22 September 2011
Quantitative Easing for Dummies
On Wednesday, the US Federal Reserve announced another round of quantitative easing (QE), only they called it Operation Twist, because they've tried quantitative easing twice before and it didn't work, so they're hoping a change of name might bring better luck. This is intended to boost a flagging economy, so the markets predictably responded with blind panic. The UK is also set to follow the same strategy soon. In case you're wondering what this is all about, I've put together a handy little Q&A about QE:
Q: What is quantitative easing?
A: It's when a central bank 'prints' money and then uses it to buy government bonds (government debt).
Q: You mean the government prints money in order to purchase its own debt? That sounds fishy.
A: Yes. Pretty cool, though, huh? Bet you wish you could do that.
Q: Quite. Also, when you say 'print', what exactly do you mean? Do they actually print banknotes?
A: No, silly. They just electronically credit the accounts of the people they buy the bonds from. They just conjure the money out of thin air, because money is imaginary stuff; it doesn't really exist. That's the beauty of it and it requires no thought whatsoever: just press a button and it's done! Even George Osborne can do it.
Q: OK. Who are the people they buy the bonds from?
A: Whoever happens to own them. In practice, it's mostly banks who already hold government bonds (gilts). It can also be pension funds or just wealthy individuals. Often, the government simply issues new bonds and promptly buys them from itself.
Q: 'Buys them from itself'? Presumably, the issuing bank also gets a cut on the deal?
A: Yes and yes.
Q: Wow! Aren't the banks doing rather well out of this?
A: Stunningly, awesomely well. They get a price premium on the bonds they already own and they get a commission on the deals for bonds they don't own. It also helps turn somewhat risky sovereign debt into risk free cash reserves. Win-win-win! For the banks.
Q: Great. How is this supposed to help the wider economy?
A: Hmm. Good question. Well, the hope is that the banks will use the new cash reserves wisely by lending it to businesses or to consumers for spending, so that will stimulate both investment and demand and get the economy growing. It also helps keep long term interest rates down by raising the price of gilts.
Q: What if the banks don't use the money wisely? What if they just gamble it in the commodities or derivatives markets? What if they just stoke up another asset-price bubble? What if their executives just use it to pay themselves multi-million dollar bonuses to buy yachts and villas in Aruba? What if they just sit on it?
A: Don't be silly. Banks are always wise and always do the right thing by the rest of us.
Q: I see. Haven't we done this before?
A: Yes. Twice in the US and once already in the UK since 2008.
Q: Did it work?
A: Are you kidding? Why do you think we're doing it again?
Q: Why ARE we doing it again?
A: Well, if a thing didn't work three times, do it a fourth time just to make really sure. Seriously, I don't know. The banks seem to love it, though.
Q: Is there any alternative?
A: No. Absolutely not. Never. I resent that suggestion.
Q: Are you sure there's no alternative?
A: Well, maybe. Instead of boosting banks' cash reserves, one could print money and invest it directly in the domestic economy. I suppose we could build much needed housing, improve the rail network, provide vocational training, invest in renewable energy, communications infrastructure, education, health care, get people back into work, etc etc. If you like that sort of thing. We could even create a mutualised National Investment Bank out of the banks we already own and give it a mandate to lend to small business and community projects.
Q: Why the hell don't we do that, then?
A: You just don't understand economic theory, do you? Private sector good, public sector bad. Private sector good, public sector bad. Private sector good, public sector bad. Thatcher is God! Baaaaah. Baaaaah. Wibble.
![]() |
| A brief pictorial explanation by Eric Lewis |
Q: What is quantitative easing?
A: It's when a central bank 'prints' money and then uses it to buy government bonds (government debt).
Q: You mean the government prints money in order to purchase its own debt? That sounds fishy.
A: Yes. Pretty cool, though, huh? Bet you wish you could do that.
Q: Quite. Also, when you say 'print', what exactly do you mean? Do they actually print banknotes?
A: No, silly. They just electronically credit the accounts of the people they buy the bonds from. They just conjure the money out of thin air, because money is imaginary stuff; it doesn't really exist. That's the beauty of it and it requires no thought whatsoever: just press a button and it's done! Even George Osborne can do it.
Q: OK. Who are the people they buy the bonds from?
A: Whoever happens to own them. In practice, it's mostly banks who already hold government bonds (gilts). It can also be pension funds or just wealthy individuals. Often, the government simply issues new bonds and promptly buys them from itself.
Q: 'Buys them from itself'? Presumably, the issuing bank also gets a cut on the deal?
A: Yes and yes.
Q: Wow! Aren't the banks doing rather well out of this?
A: Stunningly, awesomely well. They get a price premium on the bonds they already own and they get a commission on the deals for bonds they don't own. It also helps turn somewhat risky sovereign debt into risk free cash reserves. Win-win-win! For the banks.
Q: Great. How is this supposed to help the wider economy?
A: Hmm. Good question. Well, the hope is that the banks will use the new cash reserves wisely by lending it to businesses or to consumers for spending, so that will stimulate both investment and demand and get the economy growing. It also helps keep long term interest rates down by raising the price of gilts.
Q: What if the banks don't use the money wisely? What if they just gamble it in the commodities or derivatives markets? What if they just stoke up another asset-price bubble? What if their executives just use it to pay themselves multi-million dollar bonuses to buy yachts and villas in Aruba? What if they just sit on it?
A: Don't be silly. Banks are always wise and always do the right thing by the rest of us.
Q: I see. Haven't we done this before?
A: Yes. Twice in the US and once already in the UK since 2008.
Q: Did it work?
A: Are you kidding? Why do you think we're doing it again?
Q: Why ARE we doing it again?
A: Well, if a thing didn't work three times, do it a fourth time just to make really sure. Seriously, I don't know. The banks seem to love it, though.
Q: Is there any alternative?
A: No. Absolutely not. Never. I resent that suggestion.
Q: Are you sure there's no alternative?
A: Well, maybe. Instead of boosting banks' cash reserves, one could print money and invest it directly in the domestic economy. I suppose we could build much needed housing, improve the rail network, provide vocational training, invest in renewable energy, communications infrastructure, education, health care, get people back into work, etc etc. If you like that sort of thing. We could even create a mutualised National Investment Bank out of the banks we already own and give it a mandate to lend to small business and community projects.
Q: Why the hell don't we do that, then?
A: You just don't understand economic theory, do you? Private sector good, public sector bad. Private sector good, public sector bad. Private sector good, public sector bad. Thatcher is God! Baaaaah. Baaaaah. Wibble.
Wednesday, 22 June 2011
My Big Fat Greek Default
BREAKING NEWS: Greece has defaulted on its debts! Oh, wait. Apparently it hasn't happened yet. Most media commentators are still talking about a second bailout of over 100 billion euros (it may be a gazillion, I can't quite remember). This will arrive if the Greek prime minister, George Papandreou, who survived a vote of confidence, can push through yet more austerity measures, of the sort only previously imposed by the IMF on banana republics whose rulers dispense financial advice to their people down the barrel of a gun.
Many wise words have been spilled explaining the dangers of 'contagion' to the rest of the eurozone and the whole banking system. We are supposed to believe that a Greek default would be a catastrophe for mankind: something like a massive asteroid that could wipe out all of Europe's bankers, politicians and media pundits at a stroke. Only the thing is this: it has already happened. For the Greek people, it has been happening for the past year already and the pain will continue indefinitely.
Now for a lesson in semantics. Q: What is the difference between a 'bailout' and a 'default'? A: Nothing, except:
1) It is the ordinary citizens of Greece and Europe generally who are paying the whole price, instead of the bond holders - i.e. the banks who hold Greek debt and whose irresponsible lending created the crisis. The wealthy bond holders don't lose a cent. Isn't that nice? They get all their money back, with increased interest, and their risk is nil. Nada. Zilch.
2) A 'bailout' does nothing to wipe the slate clean. It's like going on a savage cocaine bender just to get over the terrible depression that followed the last one, knowing full well that the black dog will return again tomorrow, with a whole pack of its mates.
To take the drug analogy further, who do we blame? The seedy dealer, peddling empty promises of endless sunny illusions? Or the poor sap who believed those promises? The analogy isn't quite precise, in this case, because politicians act as a kind of middle man between the bankers and the people. It's the politicians who sell those promises and take a cut on the deal, which is why they are always on the side of the bankers, of course. Both parties to the deal are somewhat to blame, but most people can see that it is the drug pushers who bear the greater share of responsibility and deserve to be punished (whilst the addict goes into rehab).
In this case, the drug pushers, far from being punished, are put in charge of solving the problem. Funnily enough, they prescribe another dose of drugs, only the price has gone up - way up - and the addict has to sell all his possessions just so he can afford to keep taking the drugs. Meanwhile, the addict's friends and family (who are also on the same drugs), have to chip in to help him pay.
What is the real solution to this problem? It is called the Red Pill, my friends. The Red Pill dispels illusions. What is that great big fat mountain of debt, really? It is nothing: an illusion, a simulacrum, a scam, a confidence trick. Where did it come from? It was created by banks (97% of it) out of thin air. That which is created from nothing can go back to nothing. So what if a lot of imaginary money disappears from whence it came? Give the problem back to the banks. They created it. They can sort it out. A lot of rich people will get slightly miffed. Default.
Footnote: In the case of Greece, the drug also goes by the steet name of 'the euro'. This drug releases a steady stream of cheap credit into the user's blood system, causing a feeling of intense euphoria and a craving for German imports, which can last for years.
Update 28/6/11: I hope I made it very clear above that the EU/IMF/ECB bailouts are not designed to assist the Greek economy at all, but simply to allow private bondholders to cut and run before Greece inevitably defaults. This is easy to see if you understand that 70% of Greek debt was in private hands last year, but this is now down to about 50% and falling. Here is another article explaining how Greece is being hung out to dry, by former Citibank economist, Michael Burke. The people of Greece, thankfully, are not easily fooled any more. They have had enough of venal, worm-tongued politicians in league with fraudulent bankers. The corporate media is mostly arrogant and complacent about the extent of popular anger, as well as the causes of the crisis and I suspect they will be in for a shock. It would not surprise me at all if the Greek government were toppled by force within the next two weeks.
Many wise words have been spilled explaining the dangers of 'contagion' to the rest of the eurozone and the whole banking system. We are supposed to believe that a Greek default would be a catastrophe for mankind: something like a massive asteroid that could wipe out all of Europe's bankers, politicians and media pundits at a stroke. Only the thing is this: it has already happened. For the Greek people, it has been happening for the past year already and the pain will continue indefinitely.
![]() |
| What would Socrates do? |
Now for a lesson in semantics. Q: What is the difference between a 'bailout' and a 'default'? A: Nothing, except:
1) It is the ordinary citizens of Greece and Europe generally who are paying the whole price, instead of the bond holders - i.e. the banks who hold Greek debt and whose irresponsible lending created the crisis. The wealthy bond holders don't lose a cent. Isn't that nice? They get all their money back, with increased interest, and their risk is nil. Nada. Zilch.
2) A 'bailout' does nothing to wipe the slate clean. It's like going on a savage cocaine bender just to get over the terrible depression that followed the last one, knowing full well that the black dog will return again tomorrow, with a whole pack of its mates.
To take the drug analogy further, who do we blame? The seedy dealer, peddling empty promises of endless sunny illusions? Or the poor sap who believed those promises? The analogy isn't quite precise, in this case, because politicians act as a kind of middle man between the bankers and the people. It's the politicians who sell those promises and take a cut on the deal, which is why they are always on the side of the bankers, of course. Both parties to the deal are somewhat to blame, but most people can see that it is the drug pushers who bear the greater share of responsibility and deserve to be punished (whilst the addict goes into rehab).
In this case, the drug pushers, far from being punished, are put in charge of solving the problem. Funnily enough, they prescribe another dose of drugs, only the price has gone up - way up - and the addict has to sell all his possessions just so he can afford to keep taking the drugs. Meanwhile, the addict's friends and family (who are also on the same drugs), have to chip in to help him pay.
What is the real solution to this problem? It is called the Red Pill, my friends. The Red Pill dispels illusions. What is that great big fat mountain of debt, really? It is nothing: an illusion, a simulacrum, a scam, a confidence trick. Where did it come from? It was created by banks (97% of it) out of thin air. That which is created from nothing can go back to nothing. So what if a lot of imaginary money disappears from whence it came? Give the problem back to the banks. They created it. They can sort it out. A lot of rich people will get slightly miffed. Default.
Footnote: In the case of Greece, the drug also goes by the steet name of 'the euro'. This drug releases a steady stream of cheap credit into the user's blood system, causing a feeling of intense euphoria and a craving for German imports, which can last for years.
Update 28/6/11: I hope I made it very clear above that the EU/IMF/ECB bailouts are not designed to assist the Greek economy at all, but simply to allow private bondholders to cut and run before Greece inevitably defaults. This is easy to see if you understand that 70% of Greek debt was in private hands last year, but this is now down to about 50% and falling. Here is another article explaining how Greece is being hung out to dry, by former Citibank economist, Michael Burke. The people of Greece, thankfully, are not easily fooled any more. They have had enough of venal, worm-tongued politicians in league with fraudulent bankers. The corporate media is mostly arrogant and complacent about the extent of popular anger, as well as the causes of the crisis and I suspect they will be in for a shock. It would not surprise me at all if the Greek government were toppled by force within the next two weeks.
Wednesday, 1 June 2011
Thought for Food
Looking for a sound investment? Maybe I could interest you in a cheese sandwich? Perhaps Sir or Madam would prefer a foie gras, washed down with champagne? The latter might be more to the taste of the directors of Glencore, the world’s biggest commodities company, which has just listed on the London Stock Exchange with an estimated value of $60 billion. Glencore’s valuation reflects the fact that the prices of commodities, including basic foods, have shot up dramatically in the last couple of years and now stand at 30-year highs in real terms. The consequences are hunger and social unrest in much of the world, but an opportunity for profit in others. What is causing the problem, and is it really a problem?
The Economist magazine suggests that rising prices are driven mainly by supply-side factors such as drought and wildfires. The increasing use of land for bio-fuels may also be a factor, together with demand side causes like population growth and the growing purchasing power of the Chinese. However, the Economist is deluded if it thinks that speculation is not the main factor in the current commodities bubble. Their argument is exactly like saying that speculation had nothing to do with the recent property bubbles around the world. They forget that every asset price bubble is driven by debt creation in banks and the flight of 'hot money' around the world. Right now, commodities are where it's at; they are literally the next big thing. There's nowhere else for the hot money to go: property prices are falling, shares are volatile, bond rates are rock bottom. Hot money always wants the hottest returns.
The bubble may have started with supply-side factors but it is now being driven by speculation, financed by banks (especially Goldman Sachs). This is driving up inflation and could plunge the global economy back into recession, all for the sake of further enriching a handful of 'top' bankers, who are still receiving state hand-outs after committing massive fraud over the past 10 years (see the Oscar-winning documentary film, Inside Job).
The Economist suggests that the solution is to increase food yields. Again, they miss the point entirely. There is more than enough fertile land and food in the world to feed everyone in abundance, without any need for increased yields. The real problem is its distribution and the distribution of the wealth required to buy it. If food were equitably distributed, there is enough to provide 2,720 calories every day to every single person on this planet (far more than most people need), which is 17% more than 30 years ago, despite population growth. Whilst Westerners stuff their faces on junk and succumb to diseases of obesity, hooked on sugar, meat, celebrity culture and advertising, the majority of the poor world starves, purely to sustain a bankrupt global capitalist system of institutionalised slavery and theft.
If you read textbooks on economics (sadly, I do - you should do yourself a favour and not bother), you will find that they say that commodities futures markets exist to provide price stability over the longer term and that the role of speculators is to smooth out the short term shocks and fluctuations. This is indeed exactly how it works in the fantasy world of free-market economic theorists, where the market is largely made by the primary producers and consumers, whilst speculators play only a minor role.
The real world situation is the opposite of this: Glencore controls around 10% of the entire world's wheat market and even larger chunks of several other vital markets. Together with other huge speculative players like Goldman Sachs, they are now the tail wagging the dog. When the speculative money absolutely dwarfs the money belonging to the actual producers and consumers, derivatives markets become weapons of mass destruction, whose purpose is simply to create a massive casino where real lives are nothing but chips to be gambled. The winners will get even more fabulously wealthy whilst the losers (if they're too big to fail) will get bankrolled again by the taxpayer (you). The biggest losers, as always, will be the poor, especially in the developing world.
The Economist magazine suggests that rising prices are driven mainly by supply-side factors such as drought and wildfires. The increasing use of land for bio-fuels may also be a factor, together with demand side causes like population growth and the growing purchasing power of the Chinese. However, the Economist is deluded if it thinks that speculation is not the main factor in the current commodities bubble. Their argument is exactly like saying that speculation had nothing to do with the recent property bubbles around the world. They forget that every asset price bubble is driven by debt creation in banks and the flight of 'hot money' around the world. Right now, commodities are where it's at; they are literally the next big thing. There's nowhere else for the hot money to go: property prices are falling, shares are volatile, bond rates are rock bottom. Hot money always wants the hottest returns.
The bubble may have started with supply-side factors but it is now being driven by speculation, financed by banks (especially Goldman Sachs). This is driving up inflation and could plunge the global economy back into recession, all for the sake of further enriching a handful of 'top' bankers, who are still receiving state hand-outs after committing massive fraud over the past 10 years (see the Oscar-winning documentary film, Inside Job).
The Economist suggests that the solution is to increase food yields. Again, they miss the point entirely. There is more than enough fertile land and food in the world to feed everyone in abundance, without any need for increased yields. The real problem is its distribution and the distribution of the wealth required to buy it. If food were equitably distributed, there is enough to provide 2,720 calories every day to every single person on this planet (far more than most people need), which is 17% more than 30 years ago, despite population growth. Whilst Westerners stuff their faces on junk and succumb to diseases of obesity, hooked on sugar, meat, celebrity culture and advertising, the majority of the poor world starves, purely to sustain a bankrupt global capitalist system of institutionalised slavery and theft.
If you read textbooks on economics (sadly, I do - you should do yourself a favour and not bother), you will find that they say that commodities futures markets exist to provide price stability over the longer term and that the role of speculators is to smooth out the short term shocks and fluctuations. This is indeed exactly how it works in the fantasy world of free-market economic theorists, where the market is largely made by the primary producers and consumers, whilst speculators play only a minor role.
The real world situation is the opposite of this: Glencore controls around 10% of the entire world's wheat market and even larger chunks of several other vital markets. Together with other huge speculative players like Goldman Sachs, they are now the tail wagging the dog. When the speculative money absolutely dwarfs the money belonging to the actual producers and consumers, derivatives markets become weapons of mass destruction, whose purpose is simply to create a massive casino where real lives are nothing but chips to be gambled. The winners will get even more fabulously wealthy whilst the losers (if they're too big to fail) will get bankrolled again by the taxpayer (you). The biggest losers, as always, will be the poor, especially in the developing world.
Tuesday, 12 April 2011
The Elephant in Ireland's Room
The Irish banking crisis shows no sign of being over yet, as further bank bail-outs were announced recently. There has been much talk about the causes of Ireland's crisis and its severity, but almost no politician or economist has pointed an accusing finger at Ireland's attractive corporation tax (CT) regime. This is considered inviolable and essential to secure Ireland's recovery. Other countries are even scrambling to follow Ireland's example, as the UK announces corporation tax cuts and Northern Ireland's First Minister talks of reducing CT to 10%. So, apparently a low corporation tax rate is far from being harmful to the Irish economy. Or is it? I will argue that Ireland's CT rate (at 12.5%) and more importantly its weak tax regulations were in fact among the three main causal factors in its banking crisis. Let's look at them. Only the first is obvious:
1) Poorly regulated global growth of debt and related structures. This refers to the ability of banks to pump ever more debt into the global economy and for that debt to cross borders almost at will.
2) Ireland's low CT rate and very lax rules on what multinational corporations (MNCs) are allowed to get away with. Note: it isn't just the low rate that is important, but the rules which go with this; they work in tandem.
3) Tax avoidance by MNCs, aided and abetted by banks and accounting firms.This is the elephant in the room.
To put it simply, without 2), Ireland would not have been a target for 3), which greatly inflated the size of its banking sector and left it massively over-exposed when 1) led to a global debt tsunami. Incidentally, the debt tsunami also destroyed the economy of Iceland, which had followed a very similar path to Ireland. It too has a low CT rate (15%), lax regulation and a bloated banking sector which is now killing its economy. How come? In order to understand this, one needs to know a bit about the tricks MNCs use to avoid tax, by shifting profits into lower-tax jurisdictions from higher-tax ones.
If you are a MNC, one of the most popular tricks is to heap a big pile of debt onto your operations in high tax countries, financed by loans from your own subsidiaries in low tax countries. Debt interest payments can be set against tax in many cases, which means you can transfer your profits to a low tax (or no tax) jurisdiction. There's no real trade going on here; it's just an accounting trick, a form of what is called 'transfer pricing'. High-tax countries know about this and have put rules in place to discourage the use of tax havens for this purpose. However, Ireland is not officially regarded as a tax haven, and so escapes these rules. Instead, it is a trusted member of the eurozone club, which puts it in a highly privileged inside position. Nonetheless, Ireland's tax rules are so weak that it should be considered a tax haven, just like the Cayman Islands or Bermuda.
To illustrate this point, consider the case of Google, which moved its HQ to Dublin in order to escape tax. They do it by exploiting two well-known tax avoidance scams called the 'double irish' and the 'dutch sandwich'. These are essentially transfer pricing scams involving the use of debt to shift profits through other poorly regulated jurisdictions like Luxembourg and the Netherlands. Ultimately, Google decants its profits in Bermuda, where it pays no tax at all. The result is that globally, Google gets away with paying just 2.4% tax on all its profits, saving it over $3 billion and leaving the taxpayers of many countries to pick up the shortfall. The irony is that Ireland scarcely benefits at all from all this, since Google largely escapes even Ireland's low CT rate. Many other companies are operating the same scam, all quite legally. Over the past decade, hundreds of companies have moved their IP licensing or Treasury operations to Ireland or set up subsidiaries there to take advantage of the tax avoidance gold rush. In their wake, they leave a trail of debt:
An inevitable consequence of this tax avoidance activity is to create a huge demand for loans from low-tax, weakly regulated countries like Ireland. Irish banks sucked in a huge amount of money, most of which left the country almost immediately in the form of loans between subsidiaries within MNCs. The flow of this money increased from 400 billion to 2.5 trillion euros between 1998 and 2009, which is about 15 times the entire GDP of the Irish economy (see page 3 of this report). This demand for debt led to a rapid increase in the balance sheets of the banks, pumped up like body-builders on steroids. The Irish government even facilitated this growth by setting up the International Financial Services Centre (IFSC) as an offshore centre; a tax haven in all but name.
When the global financial crisis struck in 2008, Ireland's bloated banks were left completely exposed, at the mercy of the insane, virtually unregulated credit markets. The debts quickly unravelled, leaving taxpayers all over the world holding the IOUs. Ireland was particularly badly hit because its banks had taken on a disproportionate amount of the bad debt. They got into that position by being the centre of a huge tax avoidance network.
Most observers like to point to Ireland's property bubble and subsequent bust, but this was really a sideshow. It's true that Ireland suffered a particularly severe property bubble, as did many other countries, but this was a consequence of the inflated balance sheets of its banks, not a primary cause. Banks don't like to leave spare money lying around. If there's the possibility of using it to speculate on an asset price bubble, that's what they will do, and so they did, mainly through commercial property lending. After all, it's so much easier than sound long-term lending to small businesses for genuine investment.
The most remarkable thing is that no one appears to have learned anything from the crisis, least of all Irish politicians and economists, none of whom saw it coming in the first place. They are carrying on as if it were a one-off and a bail-out is going to fix everything. I can confidently predict that articles like this one will be ignored. Banks' balance sheets will gradually recover - all paid for by higher taxes and public spending cuts. The whole insane cycle of tax avoidance and debt-driven growth will start again. The Spectator will run articles on the new economic paradigm, Celtic tigers and how it will all be different this time. A few lefty economists will raise doubts and be dismissed as peddlers of sour grapes. Then one day the financial markets will implode. Again. Only next time it will be much worse, and again, Ireland will be first in the firing line, because it remains a plump target for companies wanting to avoid tax.
1) Poorly regulated global growth of debt and related structures. This refers to the ability of banks to pump ever more debt into the global economy and for that debt to cross borders almost at will.
2) Ireland's low CT rate and very lax rules on what multinational corporations (MNCs) are allowed to get away with. Note: it isn't just the low rate that is important, but the rules which go with this; they work in tandem.
3) Tax avoidance by MNCs, aided and abetted by banks and accounting firms.This is the elephant in the room.
To put it simply, without 2), Ireland would not have been a target for 3), which greatly inflated the size of its banking sector and left it massively over-exposed when 1) led to a global debt tsunami. Incidentally, the debt tsunami also destroyed the economy of Iceland, which had followed a very similar path to Ireland. It too has a low CT rate (15%), lax regulation and a bloated banking sector which is now killing its economy. How come? In order to understand this, one needs to know a bit about the tricks MNCs use to avoid tax, by shifting profits into lower-tax jurisdictions from higher-tax ones.
If you are a MNC, one of the most popular tricks is to heap a big pile of debt onto your operations in high tax countries, financed by loans from your own subsidiaries in low tax countries. Debt interest payments can be set against tax in many cases, which means you can transfer your profits to a low tax (or no tax) jurisdiction. There's no real trade going on here; it's just an accounting trick, a form of what is called 'transfer pricing'. High-tax countries know about this and have put rules in place to discourage the use of tax havens for this purpose. However, Ireland is not officially regarded as a tax haven, and so escapes these rules. Instead, it is a trusted member of the eurozone club, which puts it in a highly privileged inside position. Nonetheless, Ireland's tax rules are so weak that it should be considered a tax haven, just like the Cayman Islands or Bermuda.
![]() |
| Photo: Peter Morrison / AP |
To illustrate this point, consider the case of Google, which moved its HQ to Dublin in order to escape tax. They do it by exploiting two well-known tax avoidance scams called the 'double irish' and the 'dutch sandwich'. These are essentially transfer pricing scams involving the use of debt to shift profits through other poorly regulated jurisdictions like Luxembourg and the Netherlands. Ultimately, Google decants its profits in Bermuda, where it pays no tax at all. The result is that globally, Google gets away with paying just 2.4% tax on all its profits, saving it over $3 billion and leaving the taxpayers of many countries to pick up the shortfall. The irony is that Ireland scarcely benefits at all from all this, since Google largely escapes even Ireland's low CT rate. Many other companies are operating the same scam, all quite legally. Over the past decade, hundreds of companies have moved their IP licensing or Treasury operations to Ireland or set up subsidiaries there to take advantage of the tax avoidance gold rush. In their wake, they leave a trail of debt:
An inevitable consequence of this tax avoidance activity is to create a huge demand for loans from low-tax, weakly regulated countries like Ireland. Irish banks sucked in a huge amount of money, most of which left the country almost immediately in the form of loans between subsidiaries within MNCs. The flow of this money increased from 400 billion to 2.5 trillion euros between 1998 and 2009, which is about 15 times the entire GDP of the Irish economy (see page 3 of this report). This demand for debt led to a rapid increase in the balance sheets of the banks, pumped up like body-builders on steroids. The Irish government even facilitated this growth by setting up the International Financial Services Centre (IFSC) as an offshore centre; a tax haven in all but name.
![]() |
| Cartoon: Kipper Williams |
When the global financial crisis struck in 2008, Ireland's bloated banks were left completely exposed, at the mercy of the insane, virtually unregulated credit markets. The debts quickly unravelled, leaving taxpayers all over the world holding the IOUs. Ireland was particularly badly hit because its banks had taken on a disproportionate amount of the bad debt. They got into that position by being the centre of a huge tax avoidance network.
Most observers like to point to Ireland's property bubble and subsequent bust, but this was really a sideshow. It's true that Ireland suffered a particularly severe property bubble, as did many other countries, but this was a consequence of the inflated balance sheets of its banks, not a primary cause. Banks don't like to leave spare money lying around. If there's the possibility of using it to speculate on an asset price bubble, that's what they will do, and so they did, mainly through commercial property lending. After all, it's so much easier than sound long-term lending to small businesses for genuine investment.
The most remarkable thing is that no one appears to have learned anything from the crisis, least of all Irish politicians and economists, none of whom saw it coming in the first place. They are carrying on as if it were a one-off and a bail-out is going to fix everything. I can confidently predict that articles like this one will be ignored. Banks' balance sheets will gradually recover - all paid for by higher taxes and public spending cuts. The whole insane cycle of tax avoidance and debt-driven growth will start again. The Spectator will run articles on the new economic paradigm, Celtic tigers and how it will all be different this time. A few lefty economists will raise doubts and be dismissed as peddlers of sour grapes. Then one day the financial markets will implode. Again. Only next time it will be much worse, and again, Ireland will be first in the firing line, because it remains a plump target for companies wanting to avoid tax.
The lesson for Ireland and for all of us, is that if you advertise yourself as a cheap whore, don't be surprised when multinational corporations treat you like one. They really don't love us. We have to stop letting them use us.
Tuesday, 15 March 2011
Postcard from Nassau
Sorry it's been a while since my last article and I feel it's time for a poem. I wrote this one a little while ago, as I was mulling over the detritus of the recent global financial crisis and also wondering how it related to the other events of the past decade. I tried to write something which succinctly illustrated how the threads of various themes have intertwined to create a coherent tapestry of the years from 2001 to the present day. I think I almost succeeded! This is about as close as I ever get to writing free verse, by the way:
Postcard from Nassau
Here am I
We all love Osama –
more than virgins, more than beer,
more than liberals love Barack Obama.
If there’s a bond more powerful than love,
it’s fear.
Give my love to Lehman Brothers,
AIG and Goldman Sachs.
Praise be to Dick, and Paul - and Dick.
God bless Rupert and his hacks.
My golden parachute opened like an orchid,
petals stitched by tiny hands
chained in darkness in Shenzhen.
I can even hear the silkworms singing
“Here we go round the mulberry tree”,
in happy voices, thinking they are free.
They all love Osama –
more than virgins, more than beer,
more than buddhists love the Dalai Lama.
If there’s a bond more powerful than love,
it’s fear.
Here am I
hanging dollar bills out
in the sun to dry.
George and Tony send their love.
George says “Stop! It’s hammock time.”
“That guy kills me”, says Osama,
laughing like an AK47.
He’s playing Risk with Tony, who just smiles:
“How many virgins do you get in heaven?”
in the sun to dry.
George and Tony send their love.
George says “Stop! It’s hammock time.”
“That guy kills me”, says Osama,
laughing like an AK47.
He’s playing Risk with Tony, who just smiles:
“How many virgins do you get in heaven?”
We all love Osama –
more than virgins, more than beer,
more than liberals love Barack Obama.
If there’s a bond more powerful than love,
it’s fear.
Give my love to Lehman Brothers,
AIG and Goldman Sachs.
Praise be to Dick, and Paul - and Dick.
God bless Rupert and his hacks.
My golden parachute opened like an orchid,
petals stitched by tiny hands
chained in darkness in Shenzhen.
I can even hear the silkworms singing
“Here we go round the mulberry tree”,
in happy voices, thinking they are free.
They all love Osama –
more than virgins, more than beer,
more than buddhists love the Dalai Lama.
If there’s a bond more powerful than love,
it’s fear.
***
Notes: Nassau is the capital of the Bahamas, which is a tax haven, as well as being a tropical holiday isle. It also used to be a major centre for money laundering, drug running, gun running and tax evasion, until the Cayman Islands overtook it in the more dubious respects. Shenzhen is a free economic zone in Southern China, famous for its sweatshops, corruption and lack of workers' rights. I doubt silkworms stop to think much on the nature of freedom and their relationship to it, but I hope that the rest of us do. Dick and Paul and Dick are Cheney, Wolfowitz and Perle. Oh, and Tony Blair is mainly famous for smiling ... and starting wars ... never play Risk with Tony.
Friday, 11 February 2011
The Paxman Rap
I simply must share this wonderful mashup, created by my clever and adorable girlfriend, @sliderulesyou (on Twitter), with a video put together by her highly talented friend, @divaschematic. It features Jeremy Paxman dropping a C-bomb on BBC's Newsnight programme, whilst introducing an item about anti-cuts protests by the group, UK Uncut, in which I also participate:
In addition to that, I would also like to share my little re-write of a verse from the famous Eton Boating Song. To those going on the upcoming UK Uncut protests (on 19th and 26th Feb) against bankers' bonuses, feel free to take this up and sing it:
Better still, add a few more verses!
In addition to that, I would also like to share my little re-write of a verse from the famous Eton Boating Song. To those going on the upcoming UK Uncut protests (on 19th and 26th Feb) against bankers' bonuses, feel free to take this up and sing it:
Jolly banking weather,
though the country is on its knees.
We're not in this together;
with bail-outs on top of their fees,
they'll run hell for leather
with their bonuses overseas,
and run hell for leather
to a tax haven overseas.
Better still, add a few more verses!
Sunday, 23 January 2011
Bankers, bonuses, bullshit, bluff and blackmail
A Guide for the Morally Perplexed
Let's change the rules very slightly. You have your money printer, just as before, but you can't just print all the money you want. You're limited by how much you already have. Let's say that this time you're only allowed to print up to 9 times the value of all your current assets. Still, that's not bad. You might not be able to join the super-rich, but at least you can very quickly become 10 times as rich as you are now, with almost no effort. But there's another catch: you're not allowed to spend the printed money yourself. Instead, you are required to lend it out. Actually, that's not as bad as it seems, because you can charge interest on these loans and assuming they don't go bad, you'll still get your money back in the end, plus the interest. So, after a while you will indeed be 10 times richer than before. Better still, as the loans get paid back, you can print more money; always 9 times whatever you get back in repaid loans. That's fantastic, because it means that there's no limit to how rich you can get. It's just a matter of time, and to be quite honest, it's a damn sight easier than producing consumer goods, growing coffee or doing anything that might tangibly benefit anyone in a real sense. Surely, no job or industry in the real world can be anything like what I've just described, can it?
Actually, I have just described the essential elements of the fractional reserve banking system which is the basis of the global financial system. In the real world, the multiple is not usually 9; it's generally higher, often as much as 100 or more. It's a lot more complicated than this in practice, of course, but the basic truth is that banks are licensed to create large sums of money out of literally nothing and the money they create is the ultimate source of most of their profits. The complications come from the various different forms in which money can be created, together with the enormous gambling and insurance industries set up by the banks alongside the money fabrication process. These latter activities serve both to magnify and obscure the process of conjuring money out of thin air.
If you doubt these claims, please take a credit card from your wallet and think about it for a while. Do you think that there is any 'real' money behind that card? No. When that card was issued by a bank, a credit facility was born out of nothing but the bank's reserves, which are only a small fraction of the value of the credit facilities they issue. You can, however, spend all the way up to your credit limit, as if the card represented real money. Indeed, once it is spent, it is real money and you have to pay it back to the bank. If you go to work and do a job producing real goods or services, you have to earn the money to pay back to the bank the money they simply conjured out of nothing. So, would you rather be a worker, or a banker?
Its ability to create money from nothing puts the banking 'industry' in a uniquely privileged position and makes it quite unlike any other endeavour. Bankers' profits come largely from their ability to print money rather than the actual goods and services they provide. In fact, bankers produce very little of real value. Their primary product is debt, which is loaded onto the rest of us. Bankers are also allowed to gamble on that debt and when those gambles go catastrophically wrong, they are not required to pay up: instead the rest of us have to step in to cover those gambling losses, just as we did in 2008.
So, should we be worried when bankers threaten to move out of the UK if we don't allow them to pay themselves massive bonuses? No. In fact, we should encourage them to go, if that's what they want. They do absolutely nothing which a nationalised bank couldn't do much better and with less risk. Banks are literally parasites upon the real economy, and we should be relieved if we manage to get rid of those parasites. The money they make comes out of the pockets of the rest of us.
This is why we should all find it utterly nauseating to see the seemingly endless parade of bankers on our TV screens at present, attempting to
1) Justify their astronomical salaries and
2) Blackmail our legislators into caving in to their demands for light regulation.
They hope to achieve these aims by convincing us that they make a vital contribution to our economy, when the truth is the exact opposite of this. A good case in point is Goldman Sachs, the 'world's most pre-eminent investment bank', which was fined $550 million by the US regulator, for fraud. It's hard to tell exactly how much this fraud netted for Goldman Sachs, but suffice to say the bank's profits are measured in billions, and its directors were left completely unpunished. If you or I were to commit fraud, we'd be going directly to jail, without passing 'Go' and certainly without being allowed to keep the majority of our ill-gotten gains. Not so, if you happen to be a banker. They must be laughing all the way to ... uh ... themselves.
Yet bankers seem to know no shame, as last Thursday night on British TV (Channel 4's '10 O'clock Live' show), a Goldman Sachs employee told the audience that he deserved every penny of his astronomical remuneration. Goldman paid out over $39 billion to its employees last year, or $431,000 each on average, some of it deriving directly from fraud, but most of it simply due to the fact that banks are allowed to create money from nothing. Nice work, if you can get it, and Goldman is just a typical example.
So, should we be desperately grateful for the presence of these fraudsters in our midst, pushing up the cost of housing, school fees and Ferraris, with salaries based on money stolen from the rest of us, or in effect just counterfeited? I hope you have all the information you need in order to decide on your answer, next time a prominent banker threatens to move to Switzerland if we don't give him exactly what he wants, given that you are aware that even a trained an untrained monkey could make huge profits from banking.
Please let us stop referring to the banking sector as an 'industry'. It is not an industry, but a scam, very closely resembling a Ponzi scheme, which we keep falling for. If it is not radically reformed, then there will be another global financial crisis within 10 years.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









